It is 1:40 AM and i'm still up, listening to Dispatch, and pondering the following:
So, my latest question ... it may be one of those deep philisophical questions like the meaning of life that may never get answered ...
Does Dashboard Confessional know they're emo? or any emo band for that matter ... I mean, think about it ... someone (music label) has to tell them "your music genre is called emo, it's for the depressed and lonely and brokenhearted ... it's the emo movement" ... and then, as they rake in millions of dollars, live the life, can pretty much get any (emo) girl to have sex with them ... how is it possible they can still go about writing depressing music?
Sure, i'd hade to be rich and popular and wanna cry all over the microphone too ... but no really, if they're told this, how can they be TRUE to what IS the emo movement? Because does a band just get together and say "ok, we're going to write emo songs" ... or do they get together and be like "we're just going to write music about being depressed/we'll write about our shitty lives" and soon months down the road people say "hey, you're emo".
And if the latter is true, and once that does happen, what then? How can they continue being emo ... they've now conformed which has to be against some form of emo movement doctrine, right? I mean we're all conforming to some form of nonconformity, right?
So this suddenly enlightened emo band, what do they do once they realize they're emo? Ha, i know what they do, they go into a corner and cry about their sell out life, that's what they do ... then they write a song about it, but instead of saying "I've sold out" in the song (which would be a great song, by the way, just doing that crysinging voice "I sold out!") they instead write a song with a bunch of metaphors like hating the winters in lexington and behind the scenes tell themselves it's hidden meaning is about selling out. Cause honestly, how can you possibly fucking cry if you're famous and making big money? There has to be a point where all that crying you've done and singing about it has finally written you a phat enough check to where you can stop your fucking bitching.
Now, look at it like this. If this is true, that there comes a point where an emo artist either realizes they're emo, or realizes they're crying about something stupid like scraping their knee, or if they make it far enough to finally get paid enough to not be depressed ... why aren't emo bands dropping off the lists of "still together" bands? Simple, because what the emo movement represents is not real, it can't be. These artists reach a point where somehow they're not only no longer truly emo, but CONTINUE with the image to perpetuate the effects. Basically, every one of them sells out eventually. It's inevitable.
The biggest thing I'm trying to point out to you emo buffs is that every artist you listen to (especially dashboard confessional) is not truly emo. They're not really depressed. They're simply putting on an act, impersonating someone they used to be usually back in highschool and replicating emotions they once had that weren't really true emotions anyway (like their first girlfriend and swearing they loved her (when they never really knew what love was) until she dumped them and they vowed never to date again, instead write an album where each song in it's own way is about breaking up).
Now I know what some of you say. "So and so didn't sell out" or "they don't care about the money" or "they make great music" or "so and so is different from the rest, they're true to the movement". I'm going to say this ... maybe true, maybe so and so actually is true or didn't sell out. However, if you even DARE insert dashboard confessional for "so and so" then I'm going to call you a freaking retard. Better, i'll say to your face "you're either british or retarded".
Because Dashboard Confessional can not possibly STILL be depressed. And because I know you agree with me, i'm going to say this now ... Do you see the overall irony in this? You can't possibly have Dashboard Confessional and call them emo or say that they're true to the movement. Because they're just doing it to make money! They have to be! Because if you can possibly actually say they're doing it because they're actually emo and actually depressed or because they're true to the movement, there's no way that their success as an artist and the benefits like massive amounts of money, fans, attention, fame, glamour, and women could possibly not make them un-emo ... it's human nature to be greedy and indulge sinful pleasures like selling out. So you see, it's impossible they could be really doing it just for the movement.
My final words on the subject, find a real genre or movement ... listen to something like Koop ...
Tomorrow i'll ponder my response to those people who I know will try to tell me "I'm not depressed, i don't do it for the emo, nor the movement simply because it's good music." Why would I need to ponder a response, should be a legitimate argument on their part, right? Except HOW CAN YOU POSSIBLY (1) not get depressed WHILE LISTENING to that music and (2) enjoy that whiney raspy voice of people crying over the microphone?
Spork.